I think I found the original Jeff the Killer image (could be completely wrong, tell me what you think) : r/SomeOrdinaryGmrs

When Suspense is Lurking (Jeff The Killer)

FULLY LOST] New information and large document on Jeff The Killer

Do you find Jeff the Killer scary? - Quora

Have you seen me?, Lost Media Archive

Original Jeff the Killer Image - What we know and what we think

Jeff the Killer (lost unedited image of Creepypasta character

Lol this is probably not the real unedited pic. But who nows : r

Where Did This Image Come From?

Jeff the killer possible original image(s) : r/creepypasta